
The beeping of the machines. A big light close to his head, right above his eyes.
A really nice lady in blue, with a mask covering her nose, told him everything would be fine.
One of the top spine surgeons in New York told him the same: everything was okay, and this surgery would be life-changing for the pain in the middle of his back.
He would just sleep for now.
Little did he know, he would go through this experience three more times to try to fix his pain.
He’d later discover this surgery was not necessary.
And it wasn’t even the right one. It turns out, his problem was in his neck, and the pain was radiating down his back.
When he eventually found out, he realized what they were doing to him was wrong. If the U.S. needed better healthcare, he believed he could find a way to make it happen.
People told him to let the idea burn. It was a boss too big to fight. But he couldn’t let go. Even if it failed, he was okay with at least giving it a try. And when you’re okay with falling, you’re not afraid to jump.
So, he jumped.
That company is now valued at $2.74 billion.
But before the jump, he spent 10 years learning to predict the future using data.

Welcome back to Zero to Unicorn, Unicorner’s bi-weekly deep dive into life stories and lessons of the founders behind exceptional companies.
Question: who paid for your last doctor’s visit?
If you said, “my insurance,” Nick Reber has a follow-up question for you. It’s the same question that pulled him out of 10 years at Bridgewater and into one of the toughest markets in the country to build in.
This is the story of Garner Health, the company betting that the most important healthcare decision you’ll make is which doctor you see.
Let’s, ahem, jump right in.

The Next Version: A Dinner for Exceptional Founders (SF, Tue. Dec 8) - Mercury and Unicorner invite you to The Next Version: a 10-person Series A and B founder dinner with Andrew Ackermann, Mercury’s VP of Design. Seats are extremely limited.
The Next Version: A Dinner for Exceptional Founders (NYC, Thu. Dec 10) - Mercury and Unicorner invite you to The Next Version: a 10-person Series A and B founder dinner with Matt Heiman, previous partner at CRV and Mercury’s current Head of Investor Relations. Seats are extremely limited.




Think about your most stubborn friend. The one who likes to figure things out on his own and hates asking for directions. If you’re lost in the middle of nowhere, he flat-out refuses to stop and ask around.
But sometimes, that same stubbornness takes you places you would never have found otherwise.
Two sides of the same coin.
That’s Nick Reber.
“I like to figure stuff out for myself. It really has to make sense in my head,” he said. Sometimes, he admits, that’s a weakness. Other times, it leads to new, creative solutions.
Perhaps that’s why he turned to numbers.
What is a nightmare for some is exactly what he loves. He loved it so much, he studied it at Brown University and earned a B.A. in math.
Where to take his love of numbers and data after college? In 2006, still in his early twenties, he took this love with him to Bridgewater Associates, a hedge fund.
And not just any hedge fund.Bridgewater was founded in 1975 by Ray Dalio. Over the years, it has became the largest hedge fund in the world. Dalio has even written several books about the economy and global markets, like the #1 New York Times bestseller “Principles.”
Bridgewater manages money for large investors, such as pension funds and foundations, and invests it based on how it expects economies and markets to move.
In other words, its whole business is understanding data well to make good decisions with it.
And if you like numbers, here’s another one: 3,650.
That’s about how many days there are in 10 years, the time Nick spent at Bridgewater.
Nowadays, in some circles, staying more than just one year in the same position is a shock. Imagine spending 10 years at the same company.
In those 10 years, he became a partner and co-head of Research Analytics. He’s described as the youngest-ever Head of Research Analytics, building models to predict how global markets would move.
In that time, you end up learning a thing or two.
The first lesson was about passion.
“If you’re working on something that you really, really care about, that really has meaning and that you feel passionate about, you’re going to want to work really hard on it.”
Perhaps that explains how someone becomes the youngest ever to hold a role.
Curiously enough, for Nick, passion was not about money. For someone who loved numbers and spent 10 years at the largest hedge fund in the world, there was one number he never put first.
Years later, when he started his own company, Nick admitted he, surprisingly, just didn’t think or care that much about how much money it could make.
But we’ll get there.
The second lesson is about making sure everyone goes in the same direction, and helping people when they don’t, by being honest.
“We have all the right people in the right jobs doing the right things. That degree of real honesty and openness, I think, is incredibly valuable.”

Nick Reber, founder and CEO of Garner Health. (Redpoint Ventures on Medium)
But it wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows. Like with any long relationship, after 10 years, you know your partner’s strengths and weaknesses.
Nick knew what he wouldn’t like to repeat in a company of his own, and it has everything to do with autonomy to do things:
“I think the best people need real space to, you know, try things out, fail, succeed and, most importantly, not have communal decision-making. (...) They don’t have to have committee meetings. They can always ask for help as much as they want, but they’ll live and die by their own decisions, and I think the best people really love that.”
So, yes, you can learn a lot in 10 years.
But some lessons are hard ones.
During this time, something happened that would change his life forever.
It would make him leave this decadelong relationship to try to solve a problem that many others had already failed to solve.

The surgeries started in 2009. Four surgeries later, there was the wheelchair incident.
The hospital wanted him to leave in a wheelchair. He told them he didn’t need it. He could walk fine, and someone was going to drive him home. They insisted.
His insurance had paid for the wheelchair, so he should take it. It was a $1,500 wheelchair.
“Yeah, but who is paying for the insurance?” he thought.
The answer was his company. Like most large employers, Bridgewater was self-funded, which means the company paid its employees’ medical bills directly.
And since he was an equity holder, part of that money was his.
He was paying for a wheelchair he didn’t need and didn’t ask for.
This is how it works for millions of people in the U.S.
About 90% of Americans have health insurance, and more than half of all Americans get it through work. Many employers, especially large ones, don’t directly buy insurance, but instead pay their employees’ medical bills directly, with an insurance company only handling the administration. So, the more healthcare costs, the more the employer pays.
Nick has an analogy for this. Imagine a dinner with 20 people, where everyone is splitting the check.
The first 18 patrons order the most expensive thing on the menu, and you think, “All right, I’ll do it, too. Who cares?” Then the bill comes, and you’re like, “Oh, no, what have I done?”
“No one individually had the incentive to lower the price, but then we all have to pay for it at the end of the check.”
The wheelchair nonsense made him fascinated with how the economics of healthcare worked.
He started studying health policy and economics. He wanted the full picture, the full data.
“I got to see from the data the impact of our broken healthcare system on the entire country and particularly on the middle class, who really hasn't gotten a wage increase in 30 years. What they've gotten is more and more expensive health care benefits, which haven't created any better health outcomes for them. Even now the average American family doesn't have enough cash on hand to pay for their deductible bill, so they're actually functionally uninsured.”
What he found out was that a better doctor, from the very first step, could have spared him years of suffering and thousands of dollars in bills.
Does that ring a bell? Something similar has happened with Max Marchione from Superpower, one of our recent Zero to Unicorn covers.
If he had access to data such as a doctor’s complication rates after surgery, or how many patients had to go back to the hospital, he could have found a better doctor than the one he chose.
He also realized the problem was bigger than one doctor. In his words, healthcare “is a marketplace where we’ve removed consumer information and consumer incentives.”
That’s why healthcare can look so chaotic.
In most markets, a higher price usually means better quality, because people compare and pay more for the better product. In healthcare, patients can’t compare, so prices don’t follow quality.
What usually makes a bill higher is how big and powerful the hospital is in its region.
Under this logic, a worse doctor can even make more money, because more procedures and more days in the hospital all mean bigger bills!
Imagine if any other market worked like that, with consumers blind when choosing a product or a service… it’s absurd.
As Nick puts it, “It would cost a ton, and it would have horrendous quality results.”
He began to believe he needed to do something different.
But what he didn’t yet know was how many people would tell him to stop.

Nick felt he could use his fascination with data and his analytics skills to try to solve the healthcare problem.
So in 2016, he left Bridgewater and joined the leadership team at Oscar Health, a tech-driven insurance startup.
He believed a health plan was the best place to fix the system, from the inside out.
“We have all the information, we can control all the incentives. If you think the problem is information and incentives, what better place to do it than to be at a health plan?”
At Oscar, he helped get the company off the ground, and soon the company was managing about a million members.
Along the way, he used billing data to redesign the company’s NY doctor network, separating good doctors from bad ones.
But the more he looked at the data, one thing became clearer.
Regardless of the patient’s disease or age, what mattered most for the cost and health outcomes was who the patient saw.
Most people choose their doctor based on the hospital. But even in the most prestigious hospitals in the country, doctor quality varies a lot.
“You can go to one side of the hallway, see Dr. Smith, get great treatment and go right back to work. Or you can go across the hallway to Dr. Jones, and it’s an adventure with misdiagnoses, revision surgeries, complications.”
Nick was already all-too-familiar with that adventure.
So, went to renowned hospitals, and showed them the downright outrageous data that demonstrated a third of their doctors were actively harming patients.
But the answer was always the same. They loved what Nick was doing, but “Dr. Jones” was one of their highest-revenue doctors.
If he wanted any of their doctors in his network, he had to treat them exactly the same. If he tried to push anyone down the list or drop them from the network?
“Good luck selling a health plan in our geography.” Those doctors were the hospitals’ top earners. Losing them meant losing money.
He had the data, straight from the inside. But he couldn’t actually do anything with it.
It was like holding the right medicine in your hands and not being allowed to administer it to the patient.
He became frustrated. He remembered his own experience with the wrong care. The path to do something different, one he wished he could have had, was so clear.
But the system wasn’t built for any of it.
It became glaringly obvious to him that an insurance company’s most important relationship isn’t with its members or with employers, but with the hospital systems. Because without them, there’s no network to sell.
As Nick saw it, building technology companies in healthcare had always been hard, because so many localized and regional monopolies created different little moats to cross if you wanted to serve the whole country.
Remember those adventure movies where the explorers finally find the courage to enter the cave everyone told them to stay away from?
Always, the first sight is the skeletons of the people who tried to reach the treasure before them.
Healthcare was that cave, and those skeletons were the healthcare companies that tried to do something different.
Still, he wanted to fix it. Or at least try.
The question was, how to take information about doctor quality and make it impactful, a way to offer better-quality care from the beginning. This way, people would have incentives to visit the better doctors. Better doctors mean fewer complications and fewer repeat visits, and that means lower costs for everyone.
He shared some early ideas with his friends, including some who work in healthcare. One of their answers?
Let it burn.
Investors were no different. Some told him they would invest in any business he started. Then, he explained this idea.
“Any idea other than that”, they said.
But that was it. He had looked hard for someone else solving the problem the way he thought it needed to be solved.
“Who’s doing it? No one is doing it. Okay, I guess that means I’ll do it.”
At some point, push came to shove.
“I just got to try this, because I think at the end of my life I’m going to want to look back and say I did the thing that I thought might work to fix how healthcare works, and I gave it a real try.”
Those words remind us of Ankur Jain, founder and CEO of Bilt Rewards, who also bet on an idea in a market few people believed could change.
And so, in 2019, after asking everyone for advice, he did exactly what a stubborn person does: what he wanted to do in the first place.
He started Garner, betting on the idea everyone told him to drop.

How does a startup that ranks doctors get a yes from the people expected to say no?
About two years after Garner launched, the “yes!”es started coming. An investor from inside the largest U.S. insurance group and a big, familiar name as a client.
And the day Nick trusts Garner with his own surgery.
Stay tuned.

